My first ever blog for Wonkhe was back in 2014, just after the REF results were released. I compared those results with NSS, to see if they could give us an idea of different institutions’ strategic focuses on research and teaching.
With TEF results now released, I couldn’t resist going back to this exercise to compare today’s new dataset with REF2014. Here are the results (hover over each marker to identify the university):
The REF 2014 data is the GPA intensity score for universities. For TEF, we’ve used Wonkhe’s own ’25 point scale’, which gives universities 2 points for a double positive flag on core metrics, 1 point for a single positive, 0 for a neutral score, and so on.
The best way to think about the graph is in four even quadrants. Those in the top right corner, particularly with a Gold marker, can be considered to be successful at research and teaching. It’s no surprise to see both Oxford and Cambridge leading this quadrant on the research front, whilst big TEF scorers that also had successful REFs include Surrey, Loughborough, and St Andrews. There are more institutions in this quadrant than perhaps might be expected given the strategic challenges of excelling in both REF and TEF, but many of them are towards the bottom left of the quadrant, suggesting that whilst it is possible to be very good at both TEF and REF, it takes quite another step up (or a built-in historic advantage, as with Oxbridge), to excel in both.
The bottom right corner consists of those institutions who perhaps TEF was directed at – those who may have prioritised excellence in research over teaching and student experience. LSE obviously heads this up with its Bronze rating but excellent REF scores, and is joined here by fellow Russell Group Bronze awardees Liverpool and Southampton. Also down here are SOAS and Goldsmiths, as well as those research-intensive institutions who just about squeaked a silver rating as a result of panel deliberation such as UCL and Bristol.
The top left corner are those institutions who are much less competitive at the top end of the research game but have successfully directed their priorities to teaching and student experience. The standout in the top left is Coventry, but this quadrant also includes TEF Gold winners such as Aston and Lincoln.
And finally, in the bottom left, we have those institutions struggling to make an impact in either TEF or REF. London Metropolitan University sits at the bottom here, an institution that is widely known to have endured difficulties in recent years. Other universities in this quadrant may need to look hard at their strategic focus for the coming years, and perhaps have some difficult decisions to make. Competition will only become more and more fierce.
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_288781316
Andy Wilson
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-288781316
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_884408840023928833
CUPGCE
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-884408840023928833
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_2851065387
Helen Louise Young
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-2851065387
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_895350204
Dr Tracey Wond
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-895350204
Do these data tell us about their ‘strategic priorities’? Or about structural issues resistant to ‘strategy’?
e.g. I’m sure all London institutions which did relatively poorly feel they were ‘prioritizing’ teaching, but student experience difficult.
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_446814973
Kevin Hart
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-446814973
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_2911679234
Jill Murray
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-2911679234
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_41832398
Kingsley Marshall
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-41832398
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_275455302
Mary Crossan
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-275455302
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_3333174477
Dave Day
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-3333174477
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_26492916
Martin Edmondson
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-26492916
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_370100501
Mike Boxall
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-370100501
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_66335696
Claire Blanchard
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-66335696
tag:twitter.com,2013:885434935867256832_favorited_by_1172436084
UoL Research Policy
https://twitter.com/Wonkhe/status/885434935867256832#favorited-by-1172436084